In between the four show Northwest Run that opened Fall Tour and the four in California that would follow Phish stopped off in Idaho for their second ever show in the Gem State, the first since having played here on the Fall 1995 tour, and the last show to date in this oddly shaped kinda of also northwestern state but not usually talked about in that way unless by geographers and who listens to those map people anyway? The point is this was an outlier show that a lot of people didn’t bothering making the side trip for for the sake of about 450 miles of driving. You would think that after the prior Fall and that big time “you snooze you lose” gotcha show on 11.02.1998 folks would’ve gotten the message but alas, such was not the case. It wasn’t nearly as empty as that night but also not exactly a sellout by any means either. Judging from just the setlist you could have possibly have been forgiven for deciding to hang with your friends and recharge in the Bay Area ahead of Shoreline. But you would have been wrong, oh so very wrong…
Phish — Boise State University Pavilion — Boise, ID — 09.14.1999
I Chalkdust, Sloth, Curtain>Waste, Cup>WTU?, Wading>Farmhouse, Nellie Kane, Taste, Rocky Top
II Peaches>Bag>Gumbo, Disease>Frankenstein
E Simple, HMB
Notes Out On Sandpaper
–161 show bustout of Peaches En Regalia
–show has been released officially by LivePhish and it sounds awesome
The Central Theme
Wasting no time to let everyone stretch their quads and get limbered up for the show Phish starts out with the contained rawk of a typically strong Chalkdust Torture. I say typically because this version is pretty “typical” of what the song was in this era, mainly used for the energy boost and as a means of Trey-led shred. This version fits that bill perfectly, getting the place moving and setting the tone for the night to come. The Sloth continues the grimy fun as the first of four straight tour debuts and already you can tell there is some swagger coming from the stage tonight. Being a band that loves to prove everyone wrong you can imagine the backstage conversation around showing once again that people should’ve made the trip. That doesn’t really come to the surface just yet as we have a ways to go but still putting The Curtain in the three hole and ending up with that trio of tunes to open is definitely sending a message. For the maybe like three other people like me who care about this sort of thing, this is the only time those three songs have been played in sequence and only nine times have they ever even been played in the same show.
Maybe you are like me and back before the (With) part of the Curtain suite returned every time the band started up The Curtain you got giddy starting to wonder what song they would drop into immediately following. Maybe you aren’t. And that’s okay. But this is clearly not the place for you if those sorts of things aren’t at least interesting to you cuz it is kind of my schtick I suppose. Anyway, when that Curtain drops into Waste, well, let’s just say that is not the whizz bang jump one expects there. Normally The Curtain leads to something with a punch, perhaps a vehicle or something full of energy. Sure, there are a few ballad drops here and there but that’s not really the “norm” for the song. Who am I kidding though. Phish does what they want when they want. So if we are getting the first Waste of the tour out of Curtain than so be it. This remains the only time that these two songs have been paired thusly and the Waste is perfectly fine as our first breather in the four slot.
Not to worry though as the Loving Cup that follows is a pretty dang fun one. Going back to the Waste choice, the placement of this Cup is not typical either. There are only 25 (out of 137 total) performances of Loving Cup where it is not a set opener, closer, or part of an encore. And some of those are unique such as being part of the Exile set on 10.31.2009. But hey you gotta get the people moving, right? Following this fourth tour debut in a row they bleed into the second What’s The Use? of this young tour, again putting it in the odd-to-me mid-first set slot (though the math shows a little under 1/3 of the time this is a first set song). Sadly, this will be our last chance to wonder at what the use actually might be until next year so enjoy it while you can. Wading>Farmhouse is not a pairing you love to see on a setlist but it kind of works here even though at this stage in the set you have to be wondering if they are going to jam anything tonight at all.
My intel on this show from folks I know in attendance is that after the four shows to start people were just plain worn out even with that off night to make it over here from western Oregon. So maybe the pace of this first set wasn’t helping things. Could it have been purposeful trolling by the band like “hey let’s take it easy on them and let folks mellow out a bit”? I think probably not because you can clearly hear the band is engaged and playing well just not songs that are typically the pick-me-up variety so far. But never fear, the end of set is near! Nellie Kane is the grassy-sing-a-long to wake us up then a tight run through Taste clears the cobwebs even further. The set closes with Rocky Top, another wake-em-up grass tune that gets everyone moving just in time for the break. Classic. On paper this one may have you scratching your head and asking why this show of all those out there has gotten an official release. Yes the playing is solid and most of the tunes are firsts for the tour but there is a decided lack of jamming here. There is, however, a reason that Phish plays two sets every night.
Now I’ve heard stories about people being so tired and unenthused by that first set that they actually left at the break. I’ve never done anything like that and in fact would have been quite happy to camp out in the upper seats sitting if need be rather than risk missing IT which on this night is exactly what would have happened. Before we get too far, here’s video of the second set of this show which I hadn’t seen until recently but which will give you some great context on how this all went down. After a little bit of band convo they roll into the 161 show bustout of Peaches En Regalia, that wonderful Frank Zappa tune that still stands somehow as the lone Zappa tune that Phish has covered (well, except for all of those jams and songs that heavily lean on Zappa-ism-ness-itude). Bustout out of the way, they drop into the first ACDC Bag of the tour for what is assuredly just a secondary opener, right? Hahahahahahahahaha yeah no.
The song itself goes along as it does but after a relatively short “normal jam” where you would expect the rave up to close to arrive the band makes a subtle shift into a Mike-led section. I adore this whole part particularly if you watch Trey on the video as he is just completely wrapped up in what Mike is doing, playing off of the changes Mike makes. Page and Fish are vamping along as Trey stretches out with these searing, moaning notes. They sit in this pocket for several minutes until it feels like it is about to all fall apart into the standard ambient outro business but then Trey’s guitar starts eating notes and you can tell they are far from done here. Now they are searching, waiting for someone to assert with the big move to a new idea. Trey finds a melodic idea that Fish follows and now we are into a new but related section where Trey is still fixated on Mike but now more assertively driving the movement. Trey is soaring now with extended notes that feel so familiar but are wholly unique (a feeling we get a lot with this guy, eh?).
Suddenly, or at least what seems to be quite sudden, the pace and energy has increased and they move into a full-on swagger funk jam. The band is fully connected here in the type of funk that 1999 produces, not the campy/vamp cowfunk of 1997 but something a bit more refined. Page takes the forefront here on the piano as the rest of the band grooves along, eventually moving to organ as Trey heads to set loops and color against Page’s big fills. This section is top tier Phish porn that begs you to get up and start dancing. Trey and Fish orchestrate a couple of stop/starts to mess with everyone as the loop wails away. This is the type of tension building you could expect in this era outside of the typical areas like Stash or Bowie. Trey drops out from vamping along to add soundscape on his keyboard rig while Mike and Fish keep everyone rooted and moving (as much as one can in this kind of musical space). The effects take over and at this stage it is hard to tell who is producing what sounds. Some may find this sort of jamming boring or pointless which, ok, whatever, I get that viewpoint I guess. Personally I love the ambient soundscape they craft here. It provides the bridge out of where they had gotten without feeling forced or contrived and makes the transition to the next song seamless.
Even if that wasn’t your favorite way to exit that jam your wait is short lived as Gumbo cranks in to the approval of the folks in attendance. The jam goes funk in a hurry with Mike pushing it into Another One Bites The Dust before they settle into a more “traditional” straight up funk jam. Page heads to the clav to accent the dance party as Fish interjects little vocal bits you could miss if you aren’t paying very close attention. The rhythm section drops out for Page and Trey to vamp coming back in at the perfect moment like some DJ’s big moment. The jam screeches to a halt for the shift to the intro for Down With Disease which after all that funk feels like an odd call so late in the set. And here I have to again chuckle at the graphics at this video including the big puffy lettered song titles. Goes to show how far video editing has come over the years I suppose.
Here in the future we have become accustomed to Disease being a set-carrying vehicle most of the time (and oh my gosh does that song open a lot of second sets these days). Back in 1999 you were just as likely to get a compact shredder than for the song to stretch beyond its boundaries. Tonight’s version is the former template, never leaving structure but elevating to a blistering pace and almost blowing the roof off the place with the bouncy energy it brings. Trey is straight up wailing on this one, just slaying the entire jam with note after note of shred. Not content to let that be it we get the first Frankenstein of tour as closer here, showcasing Page’s mastering of the Edgar Winters classic’s big keyboarding (though obviously this was well before he owned the James Brown keytar). Fish gets weird too, interjecting some lyrics from ‘One Of These Days’, one of those Pink Floyd songs it feels like they should have teased more than they have (there is just this one and another quote in the Carini on 08.10.2010). A quick Simple and Hello My Baby make up the encore and that will do it for the evening.
The ACDC Bag is worth the price of admission alone but top to bottom this is a completely solid show. At the end of this run through Fall 1999 I think you will find that this show sits somewhere in the middle but it is a great release that really clued a lot of people in to what this tour is all about. Now go rest up because we have a double header coming next.
Take Your Laser Beams Away
There is a very good chance you know this show already. Even if you have never spun the full show most fans would be hard pressed to not know of the Boise Bag. The funny thing is that for what is known widely as an all-time great show the singular highlights are not exactly overflowing. The ones below are absolutely ones you will want to spin though.
Down With Disease
Frankly you could skip the Cup but it really is a notch above most of the other versions you will hear. But once you start that Bag just let ‘er rip.
This Happens Once Again
The California portion of the tour starts next with the two-fer from Shoreline Amphitheatre in Mountainview. I have touched on this venue (and these shows) before in The Venue Project as it is one that Phish has a solid history with over many years. Get ready for our first sit-ins of the tour, some big time dark jamming, and more. No official releases on these so prep with the aud of your choice.
2 thoughts on “At Least You Won’t Die Wondering — Boise, ID — 09.14.1999”
well, hopefully this works now…
So great writeup as usual. Spot on writing as usual.
There definitely was a “relaxed” attitude in the lots. Add 4 straight shows, and a very long drive for people going across Oregon, coupled with a host of folks that either came in from The Gorge directly, or were just local Boise State University students seeing their first shows, or just locals.
It was typical warm September in Boise (which generally is 90+ degrees) everyone was just kinda … sober … in the lots. Handful of dudes selling beers (quietly) and no real shakedown. Add additional Campus security on a school day Tuesday night and you had a very high “Security” to “Tailgater” ratio.
Add that the big Football Stadium is right across the street, parking was overall limited anyway. There weren’t a lot of tickets for sale for extras, but the place wasn’t really loaded up either. I think you could still get floor tickets from the Box Office. Maybe 6-7K people there? Reminded me of the situation at Utah in 2003.
Onto the sets …
We moved to low Page Side for the show, and ran into some very nice people seeing their first show who were from Boise. They had been recommended to see the band because they were into Tool. Cool. Glad you’re here.
Chalkdust > Sloth was ripping. Like “wake up and strap in kids, this is gonna be fire…” Trey was showing off the licks. Which was fine. Jacked to hear “The Curtain” and yeah I wondered if it was “with” or not, but somehow I didn’t expect it to be. But damn it was sharply played. If a “The Curtain” can rip, this was it. Sure there was some slop, but I don’t think anyone really noticed.
So without going through each track… no one around us was “kicking the ground” but definitely a few quizzical “Well… I didn’t expect that next…” looks. But honestly, it seemed like nobody had any expectations … or would even know the names of the songs being played? But by Wading, Farmhouse, Nellie Kane, Taste and Rocky Top, I felt like there was some good “going deep” that I felt was going to portend to the rest of the night. The Tool guys really liked The Sloth, Curtain and Loving Cup and Taste. No surprise really.
Again, I think it was a very solid, well played first set, I just don’t think I really walked away with any “must hear” first set jams. Just super solid playing. Like “This is good introductory Phish to phans that may not have seem them live before” It represented a lot of different aspects of their varied influences.
Of course the second set is where it is all at. The albeit small amount of drugs I had brought in was having the tinge. It wasn’t a “good deep” night. Being a huge Zappa fan, hearing the opening notes to Peaches, shot me to the moon! BEST.CONCERT.EVER! Well … I was excited. Also got to get another Peaches in Austin later in the tour, so … felt like it followed me in a good way.
When Bag started, I didn’t know what to think. Another pinner version which was what the next of the whole second set was going to be, or well … maybe this will be like the UIC Bag or ’97 Hampton? Or maybe it ends in 8 minutes. Right away with Trey’s chords into minor playing … you knew it was on. Bag’s haven’t necessarily been a massive jam vehicle for the band out of a few exceptions up to that point almost all in ’97? Rara Avis as they say?
What came next was completely unexpected. Interstellar space trip. Unexplainable. The whole arena had their jaws dropped. Like … what the hell just hit us. I love this jam so much… so unlike anything else up to that point.
The Gumbo just seemed like a laugh fest too. Not sure if it was planned or not, but I think there were a lot of people with jaws on the ground still for the “Another One Bites The Dust” jam. The looseness was obvious. With a DwD that still is one of the most ripping versions I’ve heard. Trey was absolutely bouncing during the whole thing. Then Frankenstein? It was a fist pumping whole set with serious mind-fuckery in the center.
Absolutely happy to be my last show of a 5 show “mini” tour. So glad that this got the “LivePhish” release, but honestly there is so much in ’99 that deserves the whole show release to me.
LikeLiked by 1 person
hey it looks like wrodpress likes you again!
great stuff, MiA. I was hoping you would give the “from the show” input on this one